Shelsky's Smoked Fish

3.7

(20 Reviews)

$ - $$$
Open
Location
United States, New York, Brooklyn, 251 Smith St 11231-4740
Contact

Address

United States, New York, Brooklyn, 251 Smith St 11231-4740

Working hours

Status: Open

Mo

8:00 - 20:00

Tue

8:00 - 20:00

Wed

8:00 - 20:00

Thu

8:00 - 20:00

Fri

8:00 - 20:00

Sat

8:00 - 18:00

Sun

8:00 - 16:00

All rating

Food

3.8

Service

3.6

Value

3.8
Privilege
Cuisines

Breakfast

Brunch

Lunch

Dinner

Features

Takeout

Wheelchair Accessible

Note

COVID 19

What should the owners of establishments take care of?

Employee health is monitored: temperature is measured with a non-contact thermometer;

All employees are provided with personal protective equipment;

All employees are trained and instructed on an ongoing basis;

The frequency of cleaning of public areas with disinfection of contact surfaces has been increased;

Reviews
1 - 10 of 20 reviews
IS
Inta Sumina 15.09.2020

Food: 1.0

Service: 1.0

Value: 1.0

I walked in there first time to try, prices are high thought might try anyway. When I ordered baked salmon salad, tasted awful, sour. Went back to return it and let them know, they failed to provide a good service to offer something else. I just through it ...

More
PK
Perry Kalmus 15.09.2020

Food: 5.0

Service: 5.0

Value: 5.0

A really fantastic bagel with smoked fish that tastes fresh and delicious. I only can't give them 5 stars because i believe murray's is a better bagel and mt. Kisko in NY is the best smoked fish on earth. But if you are in brooklyn, the sable sandwich is a WOW ...

More
AI
Artem Ilyayev 15.09.2020

Food: 1.0

Service: 1.0

Value: 1.0

Prices are very high, when I tried their food defiantly not worth it. For the price of Baked salmon salad, it was way below of my expactations...will never go there again!!! Bad service...

SS
Sara Sopher 15.09.2020

Food: 5.0

Service: 5.0

Value: 5.0

Great breakfast spot with awesome lox and homemade bagels. Also the egg sandwiches are great. Only problem is there’s no seating!

JH
Jerry Howard 15.09.2020

Food: 5.0

Service: 5.0

Value: 5.0

NYC is blessed with so many appetizing shops. Shelsky’s is a top shelf operation and it’s located in one of the best neighborhoods in the city. Peter has created a go to place for the best in bagels and all the great things that go with them

MW
Michele Ward 15.09.2020

Food: 5.0

Service: 5.0

Value: 5.0

I was born in Brooklyn, and we bought bagels from you because of the name. My name is Michele and my grandfather used to call Shelsky. It brought back wonderful memories. I now live on North Carolina and bought 3 dozen to take back with me. Two bagels we ate w ...

More
JZ
Jing Zhang 15.09.2020

Food: 5.0

Service: 4.0

Value: 4.0

The bagels themselves are not too outstanding (too hard) but they’re above average. The sandwich fillings make up for that. The ingredients are high quality, the cream cheese is amazing, and you can find unusual flavors like Sichuan peppercorn. They also sell ...

More
SL
Sam Levitz 15.09.2020

Food: 1.0

Service: 1.0

Value: 1.0

Really disappointing. I’ve been wanting to try this place since it opened. I heard they had gluten free bagels and I went in. Had to wait a significantly long time which led me to believe they were getting it out of a deep freezer or something. Sure enough thi ...

More
BM
Ben Meigners 15.09.2020

Food: 5.0

Service: 5.0

Value: 5.0

I love these kind of businesses that make one thing the best, and the rest, they don’t care! They have the weirdest collection of candies and sodas (who the hell has Dr. Brown’s celery soda??) absolutely loved it! And the guy and gal behind the counter were su ...

More
MF
Matthew Fein 15.09.2020

Food: 5.0

Service: 5.0

Value: 5.0

Breakfast sandwiches are all great, especially the scrapple egg and cheese with maple syrup. Never had a bagel I didn't like, it's also nice to have a real bialy to mix it up sometimes. Pastrami lox and whitefish salad are also very good.

Rating Distribution

Visitor recommendation

Visitor rating

Recommends
A&A Bake and Double and Roti Shop
A&A Bake and Double and Roti Shop
3.7
(3 Reviews)
Caribbean
Risbobk
Risbobk
4.7
(246 Reviews)
Caribbean Healthy French Canadian
Chikurin
Chikurin
4.2
(41 Reviews)
Japanese
Privacy Settings

We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners who may combine it with other information that you’ve provided to them or that they’ve collected from your use of their services

Current location

Let us determine your location to improve your restaurant search.

Allow Closed